ADVANCED JOINING TECHNIQUES FOR MULTI-MATERIAL STRUCTURES: A REVIEW ON ULTRASONIC CONSOLIDATION, COLD SPRAY, AND ELECTRON BEAM MELTING
European Journal of Materials Science and Engineering, Volume 10, Issue 4, 2025
PDF Full Article, DOI: 10.36868/ejmse.2025.10.04.303, pp. 303-326
Published: December 20, 2025
Tankiso Lawrence NGAKE1,*, Kadephi Vuyolwethu MJALI1
1 Walter Sisulu University, Department of Mechanical Engineering, PO Box 1421, East London 5200, Eastern Cape, Republic of South Africa
* Corresponding author: 1tngake@wsu.ac.za
Abstract
The demand for lightweight, high-performance, and multifunctional structures has driven rapid advances in multi-material joining technologies across aerospace, automotive, and electronics industries. Traditional joining methods often struggle with challenges such as thermal distortion, brittle intermetallic formation, and residual stresses when bonding dissimilar materials. This review critically examines three advanced additive manufacturing techniques—Ultrasonic Consolidation (UC), Cold Spray (CS), and Electron Beam Melting (EBM)—that offer promising solutions for multi-material fabrication. The mechanisms, material compatibility, microstructural evolution, and mechanical performance of joints produced by each process are systematically discussed. UC and CS, as solid-state processes, minimize thermal damage and oxidation, enabling strong joints between metals with dissimilar properties. EBM, operating in a high-vacuum environment, allows precise control over microstructure and enables the fabrication of complex, high-performance components. The novelty of this review lies in its integrative comparison of solid-state and fusion-based techniques, with a specific focus on their effectiveness in multi-material structural applications. It emphasizes interface behavior, residual stress development, and scalability challenges, while highlighting underexplored directions such as hybrid processing, interface engineering, tailored material feedstocks, and in-situ monitoring strategies. However, challenges such as bonding efficiency, residual stress management, and scalability remain. Future research directions are proposed, including process optimization, interface engineering, expanded material libraries, and integrated real-time monitoring to fully realize the potential of these emerging technologies for multi-material structural applications.
Keywords: multi-material joining, ultrasonic consolidation, cold spray, electron beam melting, solid-state bonding, additive manufacturing
References:
[1] R. Sankaranarayanan, N.R.J. Hynes. Prospects of Joining Multi-Material Structures. AIP Conference Proceedings, 1953, 2018, 130021.
[2] P. Kaushik, D.K. Dwivedi. Al-steel dissimilar joining: Challenges and opportunities. Materials Today: Proceedings, 62(12), 2022, 6884–6899.
[3] T. Majeed, Y. Mehta, A.N. Siddiquee. Challenges in joining of unequal thickness materials for aerospace applications: A review. Proceedings of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers, Part L: Journal of Materials: Design and Applications, 235(4), 2021, 934–945.
[4] H. Li, X.S. Liu, Y.S. Zhang, M.T. Ma, G.Y. Li, J. Senkara. Current research and challenges in innovative technology of joining dissimilar materials for electric vehicles. Advanced High Strength Steel and Press Hardening (ICHSU2018), 2018.
[5] D. Jones, J. Jebaraj, R. Sankaranarayanan. Joining of dissimilar materials—challenges & possibilities. AIP Conference Proceedings, 2220(1), 2020, 140036.
[6] G.D. Janaki Ram, C. Robinson, Y. Yang, B.E. Stucker. Use of ultrasonic consolidation for fabrication of multi-material structures. Rapid Prototyping Journal, 13(4), 2007, 226–235.
[7] D. White. USA Patent 6519500. 2003.
[8] A. Behvar, S.I. Shakil, H. Pirgazi, M. Norfolk, M. Haghshenas. Multi-layer solid-state ultrasonic additive manufacturing of aluminum/copper: local properties and texture. International Journal of Advanced Manufacturing Technology, 132, 2024, 2061–2075.
[9] A. Papyrin, V. Kosarev, S. Klinkov, A. Alkhimov, V.M. Fomin. Cold Spray Technology. Elsevier, 2006.
[10] A. Papyrin. Cold Spray Technology. AM&P, 159(9), 2001.
[11] A. Kafle, R. Silwal, B. Koirala, S. Lu, W. Zhu. Advancements in Cold Spray Additive Manufacturing: A Review of Materials and Processes. IISE Annual Conference & Expo, 2025.
[12] P. Kindermann, M. Strasser, M. Wunderer, I. Uensal, M. Horn, C. Seidel. Cold spray forming: a novel approach in cold spray additive manufacturing of complex parts using 3D-printed polymer molds. Progress in Additive Manufacturing, 9, 2024, 1567–1578.
[13] A. Kafle, S. Lu, R. Silwal, W. Zhu. A Review on Material Dynamics in Cold Spray Additive Manufacturing: Bonding, Stress, and Structural Evolution in Metals. Metals, 15, 2025, 187.
[14] W. Li, F. Huang, S. Liu, H. Wu, X. Chu, Y. Xie, C. Deng, C. Verdy, S. Deng. Hybrid cold spray additive-subtractive manufacturing with adaptive path planning for autonomous repair of complex geometrical defects. Journal of Manufacturing Processes, 152, 2025, 1037–1050.
[15] M. Galati. Electron beam melting process: a general overview. Handbooks in Advanced Manufacturing: Additive Manufacturing, 2021, 277–301.
[16] C. Körner. Additive manufacturing of metallic components by selective electron beam melting — a review. International Materials Reviews, 61(5), 2016, 361–377.
[17] T.C. Dzogbewu, D. de Beer. Powder Bed Fusion of Multimaterials. Journal of Manufacturing and Materials Processing, 7, 2023, 15.
[18] C. Burkhardt, S. Henkel, H. Biermann, A. Weidner. Influence of alloy composition on microstructural and mechanical properties of lattice structures made of high-alloyed austenitic TRIP/TWIP steel produced by selective electron beam melting. Materials Science and Engineering A, 930, 2025, 148073.
[19] C.Y. Kong, R.C. Soar, P.M. Dickens. Optimum process parameters for ultrasonic consolidation of 3003 aluminium. Journal of Materials Processing Technology, 146(2), 2004, 181–187.
[20] ASTM. F2792-12A Standard Terminology for Additive Manufacturing Technologies. ASTM International, 2012.
[21] W. Li, H. Assadi, F. Gaertner, S. Yin. A Review of Advanced Composite and Nanostructured Coatings by Solid-State Cold Spraying Process. Critical Reviews in Solid State, 44(2), 2019, 109–156.
[22] S. Yin, P. Cavaliere, B. Aldwell, R. Jenkins, H. Liao, W. Li, R. Lupoi. Cold spray additive manufacturing and repair: Fundamentals and applications. Additive Manufacturing, 21, 2018, 628–650.
[23] H. Wang, P. Li, W. Guo, G. Ma, H. Wang. Copper-Based Composite Coatings by Solid-State Cold Spray Deposition: A Review. Coatings, 13, 2023, 479.
[24] H. Assadi, F. Gärtner, T. Stoltenhoff, H. Kreye. Bonding mechanism in cold gas spraying. Acta Materialia, 51, 2003, 4379–4394.
[25] Y. Ichikawa, R. Tokoro, M. Tanno, K. Ogawa. Elucidation of cold-spray deposition mechanism by auger electron spectroscopic evaluation of bonding interface oxide film. Acta Materialia, 164, 2019, 39–49.
[26] P.K. Gokuldoss, S. Kolla, J. Eckert. Additive Manufacturing Processes: Selective Laser Melting, Electron Beam Melting and Binder Jetting—Selection Guidelines. Materials, 10, 2017, 672.
[27] L.-C. Zhang, Y. Liu, S. Li, Y. Hao. Additive Manufacturing of Titanium Alloys by Electron Beam Melting: A Review. Advanced Engineering Materials, 20, 2018, 1700842.
[28] S. Biamino, A. Penna, U. Ackelid, S. Sabbadini, O. Tassa, P. Fino, M. Pavese, P. Gennaro, C. Badini. Electron beam melting of Ti–48Al–2Cr–2Nb alloy: Microstructure and mechanical properties investigation. Intermetallics, 19(6), 2011, 776–781.
[29] C.A. Terrazas, S.M. Gaytan, E. Rodriguez. Multi-material metallic structure fabrication using electron beam melting. International Journal of Advanced Manufacturing Technology, 71, 2014, 33–45.
[30] D. Li. A review of microstructure evolution during ultrasonic additive manufacturing. International Journal of Advanced Manufacturing Technology, 113, 2021, 1–19.
[31] A.A. Mukhametgalina, M.A. Murzinova, A.A. Nazarov. Microstructure of a titanium sample produced by ultrasonic consolidation. Letters on Materials, 12(2), 2022, 153–157.
[32] M.R. Sriraman, S.S. Babu, M. Short. Bonding characteristics during very high power ultrasonic additive manufacturing of copper. Scripta Materialia, 62(8), 2010, 560–563.
[33] E.R. Shayakhmetova, M.A. Murzinova, V.S. Zadorozhniy, A.A. Nazarov. Microstructure of Joints Processed by Ultrasonic Consolidation of Nickel Sheets. Metals, 12, 2022, 1865.
[34] Y. Wang, Q. Yang, X. Liu, Y. Liu, B. Liu, R.D.K. Misra, H. Xu, P. Bai. Microstructure and mechanical properties of amorphous strip/aluminum laminated composites fabricated by ultrasonic additive consolidation. Materials Science and Engineering A, 749, 2019, 74–78.
[35] S. Yin, M. Meyer, W. Li, H. Liao, R. Lupoi. Gas flow, particle acceleration, and heat transfer in cold spray: a review. Journal of Thermal Spray Technology, 25, 2016, 1–23.
[36] J.O. Obielodan, A. Ceylan, L.E. Murr, B.E. Stucker. Multi-material bonding in ultrasonic consolidation. Rapid Prototyping Journal, 16(3), 2010, 180–188.
[37] N. Sridharan, P. Wolcott, M. Dapino, S.S. Babu. Microstructure and texture evolution in aluminum and commercially pure titanium dissimilar welds fabricated using ultrasonic additive manufacturing. Scripta Materialia, 117, 2016, 1–5.
[38] J. Bo, R. Xueping, H. Yujie, H. Hongliang, W. Yaoqi. Mechanical properties and bonding mechanism of Ti/Al-laminated composites fabricated by ultrasonic consolidation. ACM, 30, 2021.
[39] Y. Zhou, Z. Wang, J. Zhao, F. Jiang. Effect of ultrasonic amplitude on interfacial characteristics and mechanical properties of Ti/Al laminated metal composites fabricated by ultrasonic additive manufacturing. Additive Manufacturing, 74, 2023, 103725.
[40] Y. Cheng, Z. Wu, X. He, Y. Zhou, C. Xu, Z. Niu, F. Jiang, C. Xu, Z. Wang. In-situ study of tensile behavior of Ti/Al laminated metal composites fabricated via ultrasonic additive manufacturing. Composites Communications, 51, 2024, 102095.
[41] M. de Leon, H.-S. Shin. Review of advancements in aluminum and copper ultrasonic welding in electric vehicles and superconductor applications. Journal of Materials Processing Technology, 307, 2022, 117691.
[42] X. Wu, T. Liu, W. Cai. Microstructure, welding mechanism, and failure of Al/Cu ultrasonic welds. Journal of Manufacturing Processes, 20(1), 2015, 321–331.
[43] H.T. Fujii, H. Endo, Y.S. Sato, H. Kokawa. Interfacial microstructure evolution and weld formation during ultrasonic welding of Al alloy to Cu. Materials Characterization, 139, 2018, 233–240.
[44] W. Zhao, B. Liu, Y. Wang, Y. Chen, L. Feng. Properties of ultrasonically consolidated Al/Cu laminated composites and the attenuation effect of shock waves. Journal of Materials Research and Technology, 29, 2024, 3866–3878.
[45] Y. Yang, G.D. Ram, B.E. Stucker. Bond formation and fiber embedment during ultrasonic consolidation. Journal of Materials Processing Technology, 209(10), 2009, 4915–4924.
[46] G.D. Janaki Ram, C. Robinson, Y. Yang, B. Stucker. Use of ultrasonic consolidation for fabrication of multi-material structures. Rapid Prototyping Journal, 13, 2007, 226–235.
[47] D. Erdeniz, T. Ando. Fabrication of micro/nano structured aluminum–nickel energetic composites. International Journal of Materials Research, 104, 2012, 386–391.
[48] T. Hussain, D.G. McCartney, P.H. Shipway. Bonding between aluminium and copper in cold spraying: story of asymmetry. Materials Science and Technology, 28(12), 2012, 1371–1378.
[49] T. Hussain, D.G. McCartney, P.H. Shipway. Bonding mechanisms in cold spraying: The contributions of metallurgical and mechanical components. Journal of Thermal Spray Technology, 18, 2009, 364–379.
[50] P.C. King, G. Bae, S.H. Zahiri. An Experimental and Finite Element Study of Cold Spray Copper Impact onto Two Aluminum Substrates. Journal of Thermal Spray Technology, 19, 2010, 620–634.
[51] A.M. Ralls, M. Daroonparvar, M. John, S. Sikdar, P.L. Menezes. Solid-State Cold Spray Additive Manufacturing of Ni-Based Superalloys: Processing–Microstructure–Property Relationships. Materials, 16, 2023, 2765.
[52] X.-T. Luo, M.-L. Yao, N. Ma, M. Takahashi, C.-J. Li. Deposition behavior, microstructure and mechanical properties of an in-situ micro-forging assisted cold spray enabled additively manufactured Inconel 718 alloy. Materials and Design, 155, 2018, 384–405.
[53] A. Chaudhuri, Y. Raghupathy, D. Srinivasan, S. Suwas, C. Srivastava. Microstructural evolution of cold-sprayed Inconel 625 superalloy coatings on low alloy steel substrate. Acta Materialia, 129, 2017, 11–25.
[54] W. Wong, E. Irissou, P. Vo, M. Sone, F. Bernier, J.G. Legoux, S. Yue. Cold spray forming of Inconel 718. Journal of Thermal Spray Technology, 22, 2013, 413–421.
[55] K. Wu, W. Sun, A. Wei-Yee Tan, I. Marinescu, E. Liu, W. Zhou. Microstructure, tribological and mechanical properties of cold sprayed Inconel 625 coatings. Surface and Coatings Technology, 424, 2021, 127660.
[56] D. Levasseur, S. Yue, M. Brochu. Pressureless sintering of cold sprayed Inconel 718 deposit. Materials Science and Engineering A, 556, 2012, 343–350.
[57] A. Silvello, P. Cavaliere, A. Rizzo. Fatigue Bending Behavior of Cold-Sprayed Nickel-Based Superalloy Coatings. Journal of Thermal Spray Technology, 28, 2019, 930–938.
[58] T. Hussain, D.G. McCartney, P.H. Shipway. Impact phenomena in cold-spraying of titanium onto various ferrous alloys. Surface and Coatings Technology, 205, 2011, 5021–5027.
[59] G. Bae, S. Kumar, S. Yoon, K. Kang, H. Na, H.-J. Kim, C. Lee. Bonding features and associated mechanisms in kinetic sprayed titanium coatings. Acta Materialia, 57(19), 2009, 5654–5666.
[60] C.K.S. Moy, J. Cairney, G. Ranzi, M. Jahedi, S.P. Ringer. Microstructure and composition of cold gas-dynamic spray Ti powder deposited on Al 6063 substrate. Surface and Coatings Technology, 204(23), 2010, 3739–3749.
[61] H.R. Wang, B.R. Hou, J. Wang. Effect of process conditions on microstructure and corrosion resistance of cold-sprayed Ti coatings. Journal of Thermal Spray Technology, 17, 2008, 736–741.
[62] S. Gulizia, A. Clayton, A. Trentin, S. Vezzù, S. Rech, P. King, M. Jahedi, M. Guagliano. Microstructure and Mechanical Properties of Cold Spray Titanium Coatings. International Thermal Spray Conference, 2010.
[63] W. Wong, A. Rezaeian, E. Irissou, J.G. Legoux, S. Yue. Cold spray characteristics of commercially pure Ti and Ti-6Al-4V. Advanced Materials Research, 89–91, 2010, 639–644.
[64] A. Zykova, A. Vorontsov, A. Nikolaeva, A. Chumaevskii, K. Kalashnikov, D. Gurianov, N. Savchenko, S. Nikonov, E. Kolubaev. Structural design and performance evaluation of Ti6Al4V/5%Cu produced by electron-beam additive technology with simultaneous double-wire feeding. Materials Letters, 312, 2022, 131586.
[65] C. Guo, W. Ge, F. Lin. Dual-Material Electron Beam Selective Melting: Hardware Development and Validation Studies. Engineering, 1(1), 2015, 124–130.
[66] A. Hinojos, J. Mireles, A. Reichardt, P. Frigola, P. Hosemann, L.E. Murr, R.B. Wicker. Joining of Inconel 718 and 316 Stainless Steel using electron beam melting additive manufacturing technology. Materials and Design, 94, 2016, 17–27.
[67] G. Zhu, L. Wang, B. Wang, B. Li, J. Zhao, B. Ding, R. Cui, B. Jiang, C. Zhao, Y. Su, R. Chen, Y. Su, J. Guo. Multi-materials additive manufacturing of Ti64/Cu/316L by electron beam freeform fabrication. Journal of Materials Research and Technology, 26, 2023, 8388–8405.
[68] W. Wenjun, G. Chao, L. Feng. Microstructures of components synthesized via electron beam selective melting using blended pre-alloyed powders of Ti6Al4V and Ti45Al7Nb. Rare Metal Materials and Engineering, 44(11), 2015, 2623–2627.